Elliot is Out ! WTF ??

Vid Vicious · 05-18-2006, 11:19 PM

This AI is turning out to be crap ! whats wrong with the american AI voter .. First Chris D now Elliot ... next thing you know Taylor will be AI winner .. That would be seriously fucked up .. the boy has no range ... I am so off AI now

Evil Chris · 05-19-2006, 01:13 AM

dude, the auditions ended months ago.
That's the only part worth watching.

The grey haired guy is going to win. That's all I know.

lovelycyco · 05-19-2006, 02:47 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Evil Chris
dude, the auditions ended months ago.
That's the only part worth watching.

I second that Chris.

TheLegacy · 05-19-2006, 10:55 AM

Chris has become lead singer for a rock group that he admires - Elliott will have his day too. Winning AI doesn't mean that your the best - just most liked or you have a few fans with many dialers.

clay has sold more records than Rubin I think - but definitely has the more popularity.

Katharine does have a strong voice - but she may win simply for the cuteness factor alone. All she needs to do is wear another low cut top and revealing skirt to beat Taylor who like the rest of us will be jumping up and down

TheEnforcer · 05-19-2006, 12:47 PM

Chris was WAYYYYY overrated though based on that weeks performance didn't deserve to go. Elliot has a tremendous voice but was very blase and didn't show any real personality at all and it was no surprise he got voted off. When Kat is on she's amazing like that "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" rendition or the "Black Horse and the Cherry Tree" but when she's off she's off. She deserved to get the boot last week but that one song this week nailed it for her because Elliot was just ok on all 3 of his numbers. Taylor has been my pick from the get go and it's easy for the audience to see his confindence, joy at what he's doing, and like Simon said people tend to forget he can really sing well because of how much he likes to have fun but numbers like "In the Ghetto" and You Are So Beautiful" shows the man has got a damn good voice as well.

I think Taylor will win as Kat, to me, for the first time came across badly in how she handled herself this week. She seemed EXTREMELY whiny in that she complained that she didn't have the huge numbers of people showing up for her like Elliot and Taylor did. It was not her finest moment.

Bhelliom · 05-19-2006, 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by TheLegacy

Katharine does have a strong voice - but she may win simply for the cuteness factor alone. All she needs to do is wear another low cut top and revealing skirt to beat Taylor who like the rest of us will be jumping up and down

Disagree... I think the majority of voters are high school and preteen prosti-tots. Guys get the sex appeal vote

Vid Vicious · 05-20-2006, 08:00 PM

taylor has no range .. he belongs in a pub band .. Sorry

should of been Chris .. He had the biggest range and they needed a rocker to win

jacobkell · 05-21-2006, 08:31 AM

Shit's happenning.

Don Soporno · 05-22-2006, 05:12 PM

Definatly should have been Chris but we all know AI is not real anyway. Chris has the potential to go on and sell more records then ANYONE who has ever been on American Idol EVER. And I believe he will. Of the 2 left I would have to say Taylor for no more reason then Kat just rubbed me wrong somehow back in the beginning. Plus its the "White Guy" year so she really has no hope....lol

SilvercashJeanette · 05-22-2006, 08:10 PM

I really hope Taylor wins...he may not have the best range, but he's still entertaining. But I'm pretty sure Kat will win just cuz she is a hottie. I'm really starting to think that's the only reason she made it this far in the first place...not like she can't sing, just that it doesn't matter. All AI has ever been and will ever be, is a stupid popularity contest that means absolutley shyt.

Don Soporno · 05-23-2006, 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by HotInHere
I really hope Taylor wins...he may not have the best range, but he's still entertaining. But I'm pretty sure Kat will win just cuz she is a hottie. I'm really starting to think that's the only reason she made it this far in the first place...not like she can't sing, just that it doesn't matter. All AI has ever been and will ever be, is a stupid popularity contest that means absolutley shyt.

I dont know you but you speak wisely.

SilvercashJeanette · 05-23-2006, 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Don Soporno
I dont know you but you speak wisely.

Well thank ya.

My name is Jeanette. Nice to meet you.

05-25-2006, 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Vid Vicious
taylor has no range .. he belongs in a pub band .. Sorry

should of been Chris .. He had the biggest range and they needed a rocker to win

Were we watching the same show???

The reason it is not Chris is because he got signed to a band.....